An Ordinary Person

Deer Hunting with Jesus

October 31, 2007
2 Comments

deerhunting.jpgI recently read Joe Bageant’s book Deer Hunting with Jesus: Dispatches from America’s Class War. I highly recommend this book. If you are at all interested in lyrical prose, politics, and social class this is a book not to be missed.

Bageant combines great writing with razor-sharp insights that only one descended from the white, rural, American working class can make. The book is preachy, angry, sad, outraged, poignant, funny as all hell in parts and a sophisticated analysis of the politics of the American class and caste system—all at the same time.

The book explains the phenomenon of working-class people who seem to—in droves—display political behavior against their economic interests by consistently voting Republican in elections and adopting conservative attitudes. Bageant dives deep into the subject by retelling the story of moving back to Winchester, Virginia, his hometown, and hanging out and socializing with his childhood friends and neighbors.

Rather than take the easy way out of condescending to his subject matter, Bageant shows compassion and understanding in explaining working class political beliefs and behavior in Winchester, Virginia. He cites the narrow worldview, lack of education and latent racism of his subjects as contributing to the state of affairs. But he reserves his roundest condemnation to middle class Democrats and liberals who seem to have abandoned small towns and rural folks like the ones in Winchester.

Bageant argues that Democrats and middle-class, progressive liberals do not really have any meaningful social contact with working class folks. They operate in totally different social spheres which often do not cross. Despite Democrat and liberal claims to represent the interests of the common man, most people who consider themselves progressive look down on the values and culture of Winchester folks and do not make a serious effort to engage rural, working class whites politically. And that is a mistake. According to Bageant:

The fact is that liberals and working people need each other to survive the growing economic calamity delivered to us by the regime that promised to “run this country like a business.” Sooner or later, despite the Democrats’ wins in the 2006 mid-term elections, the left must genuinely connect face-to-face with Americans who don’t necessarily share all of their priorities and especially with Americans who have not been voting, if the left is ever to be relevant again to working America. If the left is not about class equity, what is it about? (page 15)

All in all, Bageant’s book is an excellent primer for anyone who is interested in working class culture and its potential for progressive politics. To this Asian-American, middle-class liberal, much of what Bageant had to say were eye-opening and it would not be remiss to say that I have much to learn if I want to be part of an effort among progressives to reach out the white working class as political allies.


Rants and Raves

September 24, 2007
Leave a Comment

Rants and Raves

Sometimes I run across a blog post on politics that is well-written, thoughtful, intelligent, and reflects wisdom and a concern for humanity and peoples’ intelligence. Posts such as this from Paul Krugman on political coverage in the media; and this one in Open Left about using referendums as a strategy to challenge the powers that be in government on the war. Or critiques like this one from Mirror on America about the silence in the white Progressive blogosphere on the Jena 6 issue.

When I read posts such as these I start thinking to myself that there is hope in this world for serious, intelligent dialogue to happen among people and the Internet holds a tremendous promise to facilitate and spread such conversations and insights to a wide audience.

That is, until I start reading the Rants and Raves section of Craigs List. For those of you who don’t know, the Rants and Raves section of the Craigs List bulletin board (one exists for each city that Craigs List has a board) is there for discussions on various topics between posters. Sometimes you will find amusing anecdotes on everyday life. Sometimes people letting off steam on this or that issue. And sometimes—a lot of times—people venting their anger towards one another over various issues related to politics.

Most of the time, these exchanges can get quite nasty with name-calling, racial insults, and using pornographic photos to boot to drive home their points. A constant pattern that I observe is race. Always there is some sort of racially-driven nasty argument and name-calling going on between individuals. This is true with Rants and Raves in almost every city that I visit.

What is the point you may ask? Why call out the Craigs List Rants and Raves? If you don’t like it why keep reading it? Why waste your time on it if it offends you so much?

I keep reading Rants and Raves despite my objections to much of the content to remind myself of the reality of the world and people in it, especially the relations between different racial groups. Rants and Raves is a perfect vehicle to learn how people really think uncensored and without any filters of politeness or normal courtesy that you would employ in everyday life. And much of the time, the nasty racial insults and political arguments predominate because, I would think, that is really the way people think. That is really the way certain groups regard other human beings and the past several decades of advances in race relations since the 1960s haven’t changed that.

Rants and Raves forces me to be realistic and more cautious about the state of human nature than I otherwise would if I were to only fill my head with the best writings. Sometimes you need to wallow in the gutter to be able to really appreciate the reality of how people can really be despite the civilized front that they might use to present themselves to the world in everyday life.


Next Page »

    About Me

    A regular guy living in irregular times

    Search

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.